Skip to content
Index Archive

S&P Composite in 1891: Monthly Averages, in Dollars and in Gold

In 1891, the S&P Composite averaged 5.03 (monthly averages of daily closes). It averaged 4.84 in January and 5.41 in December. The lowest month was July (4.77) and the highest December (5.41). The December average was 17.6% above the previous December. Priced in gold, the index was worth 0.24 troy ounces on average. Shiller's cyclically adjusted P/E (CAPE) was 18.2 in December. Before March 1957 the figures are Shiller's S&P Composite series; the index was expanded and renamed the S&P 500 on 4 March 1957.

January average

4.84

December average

5.41

In gold (year average)

0.24 oz

CAPE (December)

18.2

S&P Composite in 1891 (monthly averages)

4.64.855.25.45.6JanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDec4.775.414.84January 18914.90February 18914.81March 18914.97April 18914.95May 18914.85June 18914.77July 18914.93August 18915.33September 18915.33October 18915.25November 18915.41December 1891
Monthly average S&P Composite level in 1891. Values are in the table below.

Monthly S&P Composite Values, 1891

MonthAverageIn gold (oz)Real (October 2026 $)CAPE
January4.840.23208.3015.4
February4.900.24208.3415.5
March4.810.23202.0815.1
April4.970.24206.3515.4
May4.950.24207.9615.6
June4.850.23208.7315.7
July4.770.23207.8215.6
August4.930.24214.7916.2
September5.330.26235.1217.7
October5.330.26235.1217.7
November5.250.25234.5317.7
December5.410.26241.6818.2

Average: monthly average of daily closes. In gold: the average divided by the gold price per troy ounce (official US price, $20.67); not available for 1871-1878 and the 1933 transition. Real: Shiller's inflation-adjusted price in October 2026 dollars (latest CPI months estimated). CAPE: price divided by the 10-year average of real earnings.

S&P Composite in 1891: highlights

  • The December-to-December change of +17.6% is ranked 47th of 154 years (completed years since 1872).
  • In gold, the index averaged 0.24 ounces (gold at about $21 an ounce); the average of all months since 1879 is 1.04 ounces.
  • Adjusted for inflation to October 2026 dollars (Shiller's CPI), the yearly average was 217.57.
  • The CAPE averaged 16.3 during the year; its average since 1881 is 17.8.
  • The sharpest monthly move came in September: +8.1% (monthly average).

Other data for 1891

This data in other languages: العربية · Bahasa Indonesia

Cite as: MetalTakip, S&P 500 in 1891, https://www.metaltakip.com/en/history/sp-500/1891 · Data use terms

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the S&P 500 in 1891?

In 1891, the S&P Composite averaged 5.03 (monthly averages of daily closes). It averaged 4.84 in January and 5.41 in December. The lowest month was July (4.77) and the highest December (5.41). The December average was 17.6% above the previous December. Before March 1957 the figures are Shiller's S&P Composite series; the index was expanded and renamed the S&P 500 on 4 March 1957.

How much was the S&P 500 in gold in 1891?

Dividing the monthly average index level by the gold price, the index was worth 0.24 troy ounces of gold on average in 1891, from 0.23 in July to 0.26 in December.

What was the Shiller CAPE ratio in 1891?

The cyclically adjusted price-to-earnings ratio (price divided by the 10-year average of inflation-adjusted earnings) was 18.2 in December 1891 and averaged 16.3 over the year.

Where does this data come from?

Index levels, real prices and CAPE come from Robert J. Shiller's online data (monthly averages of daily closes). Gold prices are the official US price before 1960 ($20.67 an ounce until 1932, $35 from February 1934) and World Bank monthly averages from 1960. The gold ratio is a MetalTakip calculation.

Source: Robert J. Shiller, Online Data (monthly averages of daily closes of the S&P Composite, the S&P 500 since 1957; real price; CAPE). Gold: official US price ($20.67 an ounce to 1932, $35 from February 1934) and, from 1960, World Bank Commodity Price Data (The Pink Sheet), CC BY 4.0. The gold ratio is a MetalTakip calculation. Monthly values only; no daily series is published. For information only; not investment advice.